Can The LNG Supply Chain Be Replicated With Liquefied Hydrogen (LH2)?
Legal News & Analysis - Asia Pacific - Regulatory & Compliance - Energy & Project Finance
26 February 2021
The project is being developed by Kawasaki heavy industries and is the first of its kind in the world. It is noteworthy given that hydrogen will likely become, worldwide, part of the energy mix.
The project will receive cargoes of liquefied hydrogen from Australia, demonstrating that it is possible to ship large volumes of hydrogen long distances, as for LNG. The hydrogen will be produced in Australia from coal - "brown" hydrogen. This method of hydrogen production releases carbon dioxide and may be an interim solution. There are plans to develop an industrial carbon capture capability to store the carbon dioxide produced.
Hydrogen and methane can be mixed in their respective gaseous states, but liquefied hydrogen and LNG cannot be mixed. Liquefied hydrogen transportation therefore requires dedicated liquefaction and storage systems, which for the Hytouch Kobe project are being developed in parallel. Specialized liquefied hydrogen transportation ships are also being developed, with the first vessel already completed in Japan in December 2020.
In order to improve economics the project will need to be scaled up along the value chain which will require an increase in demand. Japan has long term plans to boost its downstream hydrogen use, particularly in power generation.
The proposal could be of interest in Europe. The UK Government Energy White Paper published in December 2020 places considerable emphasis on "clean" hydrogen - being "green" hydrogen produced by electrolysis using power from renewable sources or "blue" hydrogen produced by hydrocarbon reformation combined with carbon capture utilization and storage technology . The UK Government is aiming for 5GW of low-carbon hydrogen production capacity by 2030. By 2050, the expectation is that clean hydrogen and energy storage will satisfy the need for peaking power generation capacity and ensure security of supply in the UK. There are also plans to use hydrogen for heating and in transportation. The EU Hydrogen Strategy published by the Commission in July 2020 similarly places emphasis on green hydrogen produced from solar and wind energy. The Hytouch Kobe project raises the prospect that, in the event hydrogen is cheaper to produce or more expensive to consume in one location compared to another, or there is a surplus in one location, it could be shipped and sold to another location. Countries such as the UK with significant wind energy resources, or countries in the Middle East and North Africa with significant solar resources, could therefore become exporters of green hydrogen.
The business case for liquefied hydrogen is yet to be determined. Very likely, over shorter distances where there is a network, such as around continental Europe, pipeline transmission of gaseous hydrogen will be more cost effective. The infrastructure for liquefied hydrogen may be costly, although some suggest that LNG infrastructure could, cost effectively, be modified for liquefied hydrogen. Others state that dedicated infrastructure will be required, possibly at or adjacent to existing LNG infrastructure. There are also other related technical and business solutions under development which could be cost competitive to liquefied hydrogen transportation, such as converting hydrogen to ammonia (the Haber Process) and shipping ammonia for conversion to hydrogen at destination, shipping LNG for production of blue hydrogen at destination, or even using ammonia as fuel. The economics of long distance trade of liquefied hydrogen are as yet unknown but will likely emerge as part of the accelerating global interest in hydrogen as an energy resource.
For further information, please contact:
Stephen Jurgenson, Partner, Clyde & Co